Breaking Free from ‘Just in Case’ Clutter: How to Let Go Without Regret

By

Have you ever held onto something—not because you use it, love it, or even like it—but because maybe, someday, it might come in handy? The charger for a phone you no longer own. A box of mismatched screws. That dress you might fit into again. Welcome to the “just in case” mindset—the sneakiest clutter culprit of them all.

At first glance, these items seem harmless. They don’t take up that much space, right? But when your home becomes a storage unit for hypothetical scenarios, it starts to feel heavier. More crowded. Less like a sanctuary. Let’s unpack why we cling to these objects—and how to release them without that nagging “What if I need this?” regret.

Why We Keep “Just in Case” Items (Even When We Shouldn’t)

The logic behind keeping potentially useful items seems solid. It feels responsible, even smart. But in reality, it’s often fueled by:

  • Scarcity Thinking – The fear that if we let go, we won’t be able to replace it.
  • Guilt & Obligation – A nagging feeling that throwing something out is wasteful.
  • Fear of Future Inconvenience – The classic “What if I need this later?” anxiety.

I’ve noticed that my own “just in case” stash often reflects moments of doubt. Will I regret decluttering this? Am I making a short-sighted decision? But when I dig deeper, I realize that most of these items are security blankets disguised as practicality.

The “What If” Trap

Here’s a fun challenge: Take one “just in case” item and ask yourself, What is the absolute worst that could happen if I let this go?

Most of the time, the answer is… not much. Maybe one day you’ll need that extra set of measuring spoons, but is that worth a lifetime of drawer clutter?

How to Let Go Without Regret

The trick isn’t just decluttering—it’s shifting how we think about these objects.

Flip the Script: From Fear to Abundance

Instead of asking, What if I need this later? try:
✅ What if someone else could use this right now?
✅ What if I’m making space for something better?
✅ What if I trust that I’ll have what I need, when I need it?

Decluttering isn’t about deprivation. It’s about trusting that you’ll have enough—and that your home doesn’t have to be an emergency supply closet for every possible scenario.

Test the “90/90” Rule

Minimalists swear by this:

  • Have you used it in the past 90 days?
  • Will you realistically use it in the next 90?

If not, let it go.

This rule exposed so many of my own unnecessary “backups.” That second blender collecting dust? Gone. The pile of “maybe useful” cables? Out. And guess what? I’ve never once needed them since.

Set a “Reclaim Date”

Still hesitant? Pick an item and give yourself a deadline. If you truly need it within six months, keep it. If not, it goes.

A friend of mine boxes up her “just in case” items and writes a date six months in the future on it. If she hasn’t opened the box by then? She donates it—without even looking inside. She says it’s the easiest way to let go. I tried it with my stash of “might-wear-again” clothes, and I have to say—she’s onto something.

Breaking Free from ‘Just in Case’ Clutter: How to Let Go Without Regret

By now, you might be eyeing your just in case stash with a little more skepticism. Maybe you’re even tempted to start tossing things. But before you go on a decluttering spree (which I fully support), let’s talk about what happens after you let go—and how to make sure those sneaky “what if” items don’t creep back in.

What If I Regret Getting Rid of Something?

Ah, the fear of decluttering regret. It’s one of the biggest reasons people hold on to stuff they don’t actually need. But let’s break this down:

  • How often do you actually regret getting rid of something?
  • If you do, how hard would it be to replace it?
  • Would a temporary inconvenience be worth the daily relief of a clutter-free space?

I once gave away a kitchen gadget, convinced I’d never need it again. Six months later, I wanted to make a recipe that required it. My first reaction? Ugh, I knew I should have kept that! But then I got creative, used a different tool, and—spoiler alert—everything turned out fine. That moment taught me something: The inconvenience of maybe needing something later is far smaller than the daily weight of unnecessary stuff.

Most of the time, regret is just nostalgia in disguise. And even if you do part with something you someday need, you’ll almost always find a way to manage without it.

How to Keep “Just in Case” Clutter from Coming Back

Decluttering is one thing. Keeping the clutter from making a comeback? That’s where the real magic happens.

Implement the “One-Year Ban” Rule

If you get rid of something and truly need to replace it, wait a year. If after 12 months you still feel the loss, go ahead and buy it again.

Nine times out of ten, you’ll forget you ever owned it in the first place.

Set a Limit for “Extras”

Backups can be useful—but only to a point. Give yourself a boundary:

  • Two extra phone chargers? Sure.
  • A junk drawer full of mystery cables? Probably not.
  • One set of spare sheets? Makes sense.
  • Five mismatched sets you never use? Let’s be honest—you’re never reaching for the ugly ones.

I’ve noticed that when I assign a limit to my “extras,” it forces me to choose the best and part with the rest. It’s a simple way to keep clutter under control without feeling deprived.

Adopt the “Borrow Before You Buy” Rule

Before purchasing something for a just in case scenario, ask:
✅ Can I borrow this from someone instead?
✅ Is there something I already own that serves the same purpose?
✅ Could I find it secondhand if I actually need it later?

This has stopped me from impulse-buying so many “just in case” items. Most of the time, I realize I don’t actually need it—I just like the idea of being prepared.

Final Thought: Trust Yourself, Not Your Stuff

At the heart of just in case clutter is a lack of trust—trust in our ability to solve problems, to adapt, to find what we need when we need it. But life has a way of working out.

Your space should serve you today, not hold onto objects out of fear for tomorrow. Let go with confidence, knowing that if you ever truly need something again, you’ll figure it out—just like you always do.

Keep Going—Decluttering Gets Easier (and More Fun, I Promise)

Letting go of “just in case” items is just the beginning. The more you declutter, the more you realize how much lighter life feels without the extra stuff weighing you down. And the best part? It doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Start small, build momentum, and before you know it, your space will feel so much better.

Want more tips, tricks, and motivation? Keep exploring ways to simplify—because decluttering isn’t about having less, it’s about making room for what actually matters. And trust me, that’s a feeling you’ll want more of. You got this!